A followup on the last post:
Here is my must have list, models are examples, feel free to pick what you prefer.
- 12 ga pump shotgun. (Remington 870)
- .22 rifle (Ruger 10/22. This is one where I specifically recommend this model over others, at least to start the collection with)
- A large frame centerfire handgun (S&W K frame, full size Glock, 1911)
- A small frame centerfire handgun (S&W J Frame, compact Glock, Bersa Thunder)
- An AR-15 or AK-47
- A large caliber rifle (Model 700 in .308 or 30-06, milsurp bolt action)
- A .22 handgun (Ruger MKII/MKIII, Walther P22)
I would recommend that someone starting their collection start with the pump shotgun, one of the handguns, and the 10/22. The rest are in no particular order.
This list is meant to be general purpose guns, and a beginning, not a list after which your collection is “complete,” just free of the most gaping holes. While these will fill most applications adequately, a competition shooter, hunter, or someone who carries a gun professionally is likely to need more specialized guns.
Reasoning behind the choices:
- Shotgun: The most versatile gun available. Loads are available for anything from small game and clay targets to large game and defensive purposes.
- .22 rifle: Great practice gun, and for people that live in an area where they need/can use it, it is great for pest control. I like the 10/22 for the available accessories and aftermarket parts.
- Large frame handgun: For target shooting and things that go bump in the night. Some people also carry a larger frame handgun.
- Small Frame handgun: Carry, and a backup
- AR-15/AK-47: Good for punching holes in paper, medium game/varmint hunting, and cases of civil unrest. And to make Sarah Brady cry.
- Large bore rifle: Punching bigger holes in paper, large game hunting.
- .22 handgun: handgun practice.
- All of the above: Fun.
For where to go from here, John’s list is good.
Being a topic where opinions abound, what do you think?

Lessee
* 12 ga pump shotgun – CHECK
* .22 rifle – CHECK
* A large frame centerfire handgun – CHECK(s)
* A small frame centerfire handgun – Uhhh. Tuesday, I promise
* An AR-15 or AK-47 – CHECK
* A large caliber rifle – CHECK
* A .22 handgun – CHECK
Now that I’ve satisfied my minimum gunny requirement, I can start working on the wife to let me get the 50BMG
Got the small frame today. So, I’m now a complete gun nut
*12 ga pump shotgun: 870
*22 rifle: 10/22
*22 pistol: 22/45
*small frame pistol: LCP, Kahr P380 on order
*large frame pistol: Sig P220, S&W 1911, Sig P220ST on the way
*AK/AR: milled receiver bulg AK
*large(r) caliber rifle: DPMS LR308
[...] Robb siad he was getting a small frame handgun to round out my “must have” list. Yesterday he picked up a [...]
I have owned LOTS of guns, and dont, although I very much support, hunt. I have worked in law enforcement and have a great deal of first-hand experience with small arms Here is my short list. Ruger sp 101 with a 2.25″ barrel for a carry. Glock 23 (the ak of handguns) for real threats, and a Ruger sr-556 with lots of ss-109 and high-end defensive ammo (dont forget the magpul mags) This is my “ready kit” for the coming apocalypse. All guns are almost best in price and function catagory.
Whatever my decision, I maintain popular calibers and light weight arms with large cap mags.
For shotguns I keep four, 2-12′s and a 2-20′s. My wife favors the 20′s. I have two of each kind in the event of malfuction but I also have learned how to repair and maintain these arms. I have accumulated spare parts. Each of us has a snub .38 and the new Hornady soft nose bullets. I also have wheel guns in .357, two.45′s, (a 1911 and a Sig 220) several .22′s and two large bore rifles. For hunting, (not wanting to make a big noise to attract others) I use a compound bow and I have a set of butchering tools to prepare the game I take. I am building an electrically powered wheeled platform for game removal to be as quiet as possible while extracting my take from the field. I also plant deer attracting grasses in and around our home to bring the game in closer. Keep in mind that the smell of food being cooked also travels and will attract starving, desperate people, therefore a community effort may be more ideal for protection and survival. I also have horses available for transportation. Most of all, keep in shape. Survival demands energy.